The Absolute Best Pizza in Fayetteville [Updated 2025]

I’ve scoured the city, indulging in slice after cheesy slice, and I’m here to share the results of my delicious adventure. After reviewing 12 top locations, I’ve unearthed some truly mouthwatering pies that you won't want to miss.

As someone who believes that pizza is one of life’s greatest pleasures, I’ve tasted everything from classic margherita to daring specialty creations. I’ve honed my palate to distinguish the good from the truly extraordinary, and let me tell you, Fayetteville is bursting with pizza perfection! Whether you're a local or just passing through, prepare to discover the best spots that will have you saying, “One more slice, please!”

Gocha's Breakfast Bar

Highlights
Superb customer service
Delicious chicken wrap
Amazing passion fruit margarita
Great food presentation
Freshly squeezed orange juice

Gocha’s Breakfast Bar is not your typical pizza joint, but it undeniably serves up some delicious surprises. As I stepped inside, I was greeted by the warmth of the staff, showcasing their superb customer service—a delightful start to any meal!

While I was there for the pizza, I couldn’t resist trying their chicken wrap, which was a savory treat bursting with flavor. The decor and food presentation had a flair that drew me in even more. And, speaking of flair, you must try their amazing passion fruit margarita; it elevated my dining experience to an entirely new level.

Though Gocha's may not be a pizza purveyor in the traditional sense, the freshness and quality of their ingredients reminded me of what makes great pizza—everything made from scratch! I found myself daydreaming about a pizza topped with their freshly squeezed orange juice as a drizzle. It’s an unusual concept but perfectly embodies the charm of Fayetteville's food scene.

For a unique twist on a breakfast bar with potential pizza-like creations, Gocha’s is well worth the visit!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Atlanta.

Da Loaded Mac

Highlights
Unique mac and cheese options
Signature jerk sauce
Always warm and fresh
Generous portions
Loved by locals

Da Loaded Mac has quickly become a standout destination for pizza lovers in Fayetteville, and I had the pleasure of indulging in their offerings. Prepare yourself for a delightful culinary adventure, as Da Loaded Mac takes the familiar concept of pizza and merges it with the irresistible comfort of mac and cheese.

What immediately caught my attention was their unique twist—mac and cheese pizzas that marry two beloved dishes into one heavenly delight. I opted for the signature jerk sauce, which added a piquant kick to my slice that was nothing short of exhilarating. Each bite was an experience, as the flavors danced harmoniously together, creating an explosion of taste that kept me coming back for more.

The portions are impressively generous, ensuring that you won't leave feeling shortchanged. Each pizza is served fresh and warm, providing the perfect texture for that ultimate cheesy pull. It’s no wonder the locals can’t stop raving about this hidden gem! Overall, Da Loaded Mac offers a delightful spin on traditional pizza that’s not only satisfying but also inventive. If you're seeking a pizza experience that’s both fun and flavorsome, make sure to stop by Da Loaded Mac—you won’t regret it! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Atlanta.

The Italian Oven Restaurant

Highlights
Homemade local Italian food
Prompt and attentive service
Friendly staff ambiance
Uniquely crafted dishes
Highly recommended Fettuccine

Tucked away in the bustling heart of Fayetteville, The Italian Oven Restaurant is a delightful gem that truly celebrates homemade Italian cuisine. From the moment I stepped inside, I was greeted by a friendly staff that exuded warmth and charm, instantly setting the tone for an enjoyable dining experience. The ambiance, characterized by rustic decor and inviting aromas, made me feel like I was dining in a traditional Italian kitchen.

Now, let’s talk about the pizza! The crust was a perfect balance of crisp and chewy, providing an excellent base for the stunning array of toppings. Each slice was generously adorned with fresh ingredients that popped with flavor, making every bite a blissful adventure. I was particularly impressed by their unique combinations, showcasing the creativity that The Italian Oven is known for.

While there, I couldn’t resist trying their highly recommended Fettuccine, which was equally impressive and showcased their knack for uniquely crafted dishes. Paired with prompt and attentive service, my visit was nothing short of spectacular. If you're on the hunt for the best pizza in Fayetteville, The Italian Oven should definitely be on your list—you won’t be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Atlanta.

Pizza 54

Highlights
Great service by friendly staff
Delicious New Haven-style crust
Flavorful Meat Pie and pizzas
Prompt delivery and fresh taste
Excellent value for your money

Pizza 54 has truly earned its stripes in the competitive landscape of Fayetteville pizza. From the moment I walked through the door, the friendly staff greeted me with warm smiles, setting the tone for a delightful meal. I opted for the Meat Pie, which was a delectable blend of savory toppings that burst with flavor. The New Haven-style crust was simply mesmerizing – perfectly crispy on the outside yet wonderfully chewy within. It provided a delightful backdrop for the generous toppings.

What stood out even more was the value for money. With prices that won't break the bank, you're treated to a feast that doesn't skimp on quality. The delivery service was punctual; there’s nothing like digging into a fresh pizza just moments after it leaves the oven. Each bite was a reminder of how pizza can bring joy, and I couldn't help but feel a twinge of excitement with each slice. If you're in the mood for delicious pizza with a side of excellent service, I wholeheartedly recommend giving Pizza 54 a visit. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Marietta.

Anthony's Pizzeria

Stepping into Anthony's Pizzeria felt like a warm embrace from a cozy Italian kitchen. The aroma of freshly baked dough danced in the air, promising delightful bites. I opted for their signature Margherita pizza, and oh, what a treat— the perfect harmony of tangy tomato sauce, creamy mozzarella, and fragrant basil! Each slice was a symphony of flavors, with a crust that struck the ideal balance between crispy and chewy. The staff was friendly, elevating the welcoming atmosphere. If you're hunting for a slice of heaven in Fayetteville, Anthony's should definitely be on your radar! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Atlanta.

Tour de Italy

Tour de Italy truly takes you on a delicious culinary journey! The moment I walked in, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizza wrapped around me like a warm hug. I tried their signature Margherita, and it was a delightful dance of flavors—crispy crust, fragrant basil, and gooey mozzarella harmonizing perfectly. The lightness of the crust made each bite exhilarating rather than heavy. The ambiance is charming, adding a cozy touch to your dining experience. If you're on the lookout for a pizza that feels like a slice of Italy in every bite, Tour de Italy is an absolute must-visit! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Atlanta.

Partners II Pizza Fayetteville

Nestled in the heart of Fayetteville, Partners II Pizza is a delightful gem that never fails to please. With a crust that balances chewy and crispy textures, each bite is a harmonious blend of toppings bursting with flavor. Their signature pepperoni pie is a must-try, with just the right amount of spice to keep you coming back for more. The cozy atmosphere paired with friendly service makes it an ideal spot for a casual night out. If you’re hunting for a slice that’s both savory and satisfying, look no further—Partners II truly stands out in the pizza scene!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Atlanta.

Your Pie Pizza

The moment I stepped into Your Pie Pizza, I was greeted by the wonderful aroma of fresh ingredients. Their make-your-own pizza option stole the show, allowing me to combine a delightful smoky barbecue sauce with toppings like succulent pulled pork and zesty jalapeños. Every bite was a symphony of flavors, perfectly balanced by a crisp, thin crust. The vibrant ambiance added to the joy, making it a perfect spot for families and friends alike. If you're in Fayetteville and craving a slice that sparks joy, Your Pie is definitely a place worth indulging in! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Atlanta.

ENZO Steakhouse & Bar

Nestled in the heart of Fayetteville, ENZO Steakhouse & Bar surprises with its delightful pizza. The crust is a beautifully crispy masterpiece, perfectly charred while remaining tender. I opted for the Margherita, featuring fresh basil and a rich tomato sauce that dances on the palate. The mozzarella is delightfully gooey, just how I like it! Their blend of flavors strikes the right balance, making each bite a mouthwatering experience. Don’t overlook this culinary gem for pizza; it’s a perfect blend of elegance and comfort. If you’re in the mood for a slice of creativity, ENZO is the place to be!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Norcross.

Oz Pizza- Fairburn

Upon stepping into Oz Pizza- Fairburn, the inviting aroma of freshly baked dough enveloped me like a warm hug. The thin crust was a delightful revelation, perfectly crisp yet wonderfully chewy. I savored the classic Margherita, where vibrant, ripe tomatoes and creamy mozzarella danced atop a canvas of rich basil. Each bite was a symphony of flavors—simply enchanting! Their creative specialty pizzas offer a delightful twist for the adventurous palate. With friendly service and a cozy atmosphere, Oz Pizza captivates not just the taste buds but the heart. I can confidently say, it's a slice of Fayetteville's pizza paradise! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best pasta in Atlanta.

Murray's In A Hurry

Nestled in the heart of Fayetteville, Murray's In A Hurry whisks you away on a flavor adventure! Their thin-crust pizza strikes the perfect balance between crispy and chewy, topped with a symphony of fresh ingredients. I savored the pepperoni and jalapeño combo, where spicy meets savory in blissful harmony. The efficient service and cozy vibe make it a great spot for a quick bite or lingering laughter. If you’re in search of a delicious pizza that doesn’t compromise on quality, Murray's is a delightful stop in the Fayetteville pizza scene! 🍕✨

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Brookhaven.

Positano Pizza Napoletana - Peachtree City

During my visit to Positano Pizza Napoletana, I was transported straight to Naples with their authentic Neapolitan pies. The crust was perfectly blistered, striking that delightful balance between crispy and chewy. I indulged in their Margherita, adorned with fresh basil and vibrant San Marzano tomatoes, which was a celebration of simplicity and flavor. Each bite was a harmonious blend of richness and freshness that left me craving more. The cozy ambiance and attentive staff enhanced the experience, making me feel right at home. For anyone in search of the best pizza in Fayetteville, Positano is a must-try gem!

You might also want to check out the best pancakes in Atlanta.