Atlanta's Best Pies [Updated 2024]

In my quest to find the most delectable pies in Atlanta, I embarked on a mouth-watering journey of taste and exploration. After sampling a staggering 12 pies from various renowned bakeries and hidden gems, I can confidently proclaim that these are indeed the best pies in Atlanta.

From classic favorites like apple and cherry, to unique creations such as pecan praline and bourbon-infused flavors, each pie has been carefully selected based on its impeccable taste, texture, and overall presentation. Join me as we traverse through the bustling streets of Atlanta to uncover the hidden treasures of the city's pie scene, one slice at a time.

Panbury's Double Crust Pies

Highlights
Hidden gem
Friendly staff
Great selection
Delicious pies

From the moment I stepped into Panbury's Double Crust Pies, I knew I had stumbled upon a hidden gem in the heart of Atlanta. The warm and inviting atmosphere only added to the anticipation of tasting their delicious pies.

The staff at Panbury's was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable. They patiently walked me through their extensive menu, which boasted an impressive selection of savory and sweet pies. From classics like chicken pot pie to exotic options such as lamb curry, there was something to satisfy every craving.

But it was the pies themselves that truly stole the show. Each bite was a flavorful explosion, with the flaky double crust perfectly complementing the mouthwatering fillings. Whether I was indulging in a traditional apple pie or trying their unique Nutella-filled creation, the quality of the ingredients and the attention to detail was evident.

What I loved most about Panbury's is their commitment to making everything from scratch. From the handmade pastry to the use of locally sourced ingredients, it's clear that they take pride in every pie they create.

If you're a pie aficionado like me, Panbury's Double Crust Pies is a must-visit destination in Atlanta. This hidden gem will leave you with a happy belly and a newfound appreciation for the art of pie-making. Don't miss out on this delightful experience!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Atlanta.

Southern Baked Pie Company

Highlights
Supreme quality
Best customer service
Well-packaged delivery
Delicious sweet and savory pies
Friendly and accommodating staff

From the moment I walked into Southern Baked Pie Company, I could tell that they were all about supreme quality. The display case was filled with an array of delicious sweet and savory pies that tempted my taste buds. The staff was incredibly friendly and provided the best customer service I've experienced in a pie shop.

I opted for a few different flavors to truly get a sense of what Southern Baked Pie Company had to offer. From the first bite, I was blown away by the flaky crust and the perfectly balanced fillings. Each pie was a unique combination of flavors that melded together beautifully.

The packaging was also worth mentioning. The pies came in sturdy boxes that kept them from sliding around during transport. The attention to detail showed just how much care is taken at Southern Baked Pie Company.

One thing that really stood out to me was how accommodating the staff was. They listened to my preferences and made recommendations based on what I was looking for. They even made a special pie for me when I mentioned a dietary restriction. It was a thoughtful gesture that made me feel like a valued customer.

If you're in Atlanta and looking for a place to satisfy your pie cravings, I highly recommend Southern Baked Pie Company. Their delicious pies, friendly staff, and well-packaged delivery make for an exceptional experience. Trust me, you won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Atlanta.

Southern Baked Pie Company | Mail Order and Georgia Pie Shops

Highlights
Excellent pies
Variety of flavors
Helpful and friendly staff
Great customer service
Tasty and delicious pies

Upon entering Southern Baked Pie Company, I was greeted with the sweet and inviting aroma of freshly baked pies. The display case showcased an array of excellent pies, each one more tempting than the last. From classic flavors like apple and pecan to unique creations like caramel pumpkin and chocolate chess, they offered a variety of flavors that catered to all taste preferences.

The helpful and friendly staff guided me through the menu, providing suggestions and answering my endless questions. Their passion for pies was contagious, and their knowledge about the ingredients and baking process was impressive.

Not only did the staff excel in their customer service, but the pies themselves were equally wonderful. The first bite of the pie reminded me why I love this classic dessert so much. Each slice was like a little piece of heaven, with a flaky crust and a luscious filling bursting with flavor. It was clear that each pie was crafted with care and attention to detail.

What impressed me the most was the dedication to using fresh and high-quality ingredients. Each bite was a testament to the company's commitment to perfection. The delicious combination of textures and flavors left me craving for more.

In conclusion, Southern Baked Pie Company | Mail Order and Georgia Pie Shops are a must-visit for any pie lover in Atlanta. The great customer service, combined with the sheer indulgence of their tasty and delicious pies, makes for an unforgettable experience. So, indulge your sweet tooth and satisfy your pie cravings at this amazing establishment. You won't be disappointed!

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Atlanta.

Highland Bakery

Oh, Highland Bakery in Atlanta, what a treat! The moment I sank my teeth into their decadent pies, my taste buds blasted off to pie paradise. With a wide range of flavors, from classic apple pie to inventive creations like bourbon pecan, Highland Bakery knows how to make a slice of heaven. Their flaky crusts and generous fillings left me craving for more. Don't miss out on this hidden gem when exploring Atlanta's best pies!

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Atlanta.

Five Daughters Bakery | Ponce City Market

Five Daughters Bakery at Ponce City Market in Atlanta is a delightful treasure trove for pie lovers. Their perfectly flaky crusts hold a burst of flavors that will make your taste buds dance. From classic apple to unique creations like bourbon chocolate, this place knows how to tease your senses. It's a must-visit for any pie aficionado in Atlanta.

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Atlanta.

Humble Pie

Humble Pie in Atlanta is a hidden gem for pie lovers. Their handmade pies are exquisite and will make your taste buds dance with joy. From classic flavors like apple to unique creations like bourbon pecan, every bite is a slice of bliss. Don't miss this little slice of heaven!

You might also want to check out the best pancakes in Atlanta.

Five Daughters Bakery | Westside Provisions

Five Daughters Bakery | Westside Provisions, an absolute gem for pie lovers in Atlanta! Their flaky crusts are practically magic, while the fillings burst with heavenly flavor. Every bite feels like a sweet embrace, transporting you to a blissful pie paradise. You simply must try it!

You might also want to check out the best asian restaurants in Atlanta.

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop Sandy Springs GA

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop in Sandy Springs GA is an absolute delight! Their pies are like a symphony on my taste buds. The flaky crust and velvety fillings left me speechless. I highly recommend trying their I-40 Pecan pie, it's a slice of heaven on Earth. Trust me, you won't regret it!

You might also want to check out the best cheesesteak in Atlanta.

Aunt Evelyn's Peach Cobbler

While some might debate whether peach cobbler technically falls under the pie category, Aunt Evelyn's creation deserves a place in any discussion of the best pies in Atlanta. Bursting with juicy Georgia peaches and topped with a buttery, golden crust, it offers a sumptuous balance of sweetness and tanginess. The crust, beautifully flaky and subtly spiced, provides the perfect vessel for the luscious peach filling. Each bite is like a warm, comforting hug from a beloved aunt. So, if you have a soft spot for peachy delights, don't miss Aunt Evelyn's Peach Cobbler on your pie-tasting journey in Atlanta!

You might also want to check out the best biscuits in Atlanta.

Coffyn Pyes

Coffyn Pyes in Atlanta is a delightful pie shop that will have you craving seconds. Their pies are heavenly and bursting with flavor. From the warm, flaky crust to the luscious fillings, each bite is pure bliss. Don't miss their signature pecan pie—it's a game changer.

You might also want to check out the best korean bbq in Atlanta.

The Little Tart Bakeshop

Oh boy, where do I even start with The Little Tart Bakeshop in Atlanta? Let me tell you, it was like a little slice of pie heaven in the heart of the city. From the moment I walked in, the sweet aroma of freshly baked goodies enveloped me, and I knew this place was something special. The sheer artistry of their pies blew me away. I had the pleasure of indulging in their seasonal fruit pie, and let me just say, it was a masterpiece. The crust was flaky and buttery, the filling bursting with juicy, perfectly ripened fruit. Every bite was a delightful explosion of flavors, dancing on my taste buds. And don't even get me started on their creative flavor combinations. Who would have thought that blackberry and lavender could be a match made in pie heaven? Trust me, it was divine. The Little Tart Bakeshop has truly mastered the art of pie-making, and I can confidently say that their pies are truly some of the best in Atlanta.

Sweet Auburn Bakery

Sweet Auburn Bakery in Atlanta is truly a pie lover's paradise. From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for a treat. Their pies are not only beautifully presented, but each bite is a heavenly explosion of flavors. From classic apple to decadent chocolate, there's a pie for every palate. Don't miss out on this delicious gem in Atlanta!