The Absolute Best Pie in Athens [Updated 2025]

Having sampled numerous pies across Athens GA, I can confidently say that I have uncovered some hidden gems that will satisfy any pie lover's cravings. From flaky crusts to decadent fillings, this guide showcases the top five pie destinations in the city.

Whether you have a sweet tooth or prefer a savory delight, Athens GA has plenty of options to tantalize your taste buds. Get ready to embark on a mouthwatering journey as I reveal the finest pie establishments that Athens GA has to offer.

Don't miss out on this delectable adventure to discover the best pie in Athens GA!

Sweetie Pie by Savie

Highlights
Adorable little shop
Unique fun flavors
Great prices
Amazing customer service
Gluten free options

As I strolled along the streets of Athens, my search for the best pie in town led me to an adorable little shop called Sweetie Pie by Savie. Nestled amongst the bustling city, this hidden gem grabbed my attention with its charming exterior.

Upon stepping inside, I was greeted with a warm and inviting atmosphere. The delightful aroma of freshly baked pies wafted through the air, eliciting an irresistible longing in my taste buds. The display counter showcased an array of pies, each adorned with unique and fun flavors that piqued my curiosity.

The friendly staff behind the counter eagerly assisted me in selecting the perfect slice of pie. With their amazing customer service, they patiently answered my endless inquiries and offered insightful recommendations. Not only that, but they also explained that Sweetie Pie by Savie caters to a wide range of dietary needs, including gluten-free options.

As I took my first bite, I was transported to pie paradise. The crust was perfectly flaky and golden, providing a satisfying crunch with each mouthful. The fillings were a symphony of flavors, expertly blended, resulting in a harmonious explosion on my palate. From classic apple to unconventional creations like raspberry coconut, Sweetie Pie by Savie truly pushes the boundaries of pie-making.

What impressed me even more was that despite the outstanding quality, the prices at Sweetie Pie by Savie were great. I felt like I was getting a slice of heaven without breaking the bank.

In conclusion, Sweetie Pie by Savie is a delightful haven for pie lovers in Athens. With its cozy atmosphere, unique flavors, exceptional customer service, and affordability, it has easily earned a spot as one of the top contenders for the title of best pie in Athens.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Marietta.

Bee's Knees Bakery

Highlights
Beautiful birthday cake
Impressive custom pies
Delicious lemon meringue pie
Wide variety of cupcakes

Upon entering Bee's Knees Bakery, I was captivated by the aroma of freshly baked treats wafting through the air. As I approached the display counter, my eyes were immediately drawn to a beautiful birthday cake that was intricately decorated with vibrant colors and delicate frosting. It was a feast for the eyes, and I couldn't resist indulging in a slice.

But let's not forget the main attraction: the pies. Bee's Knees Bakery truly excels in their impressive custom pies. Each slice was a handcrafted masterpiece, with flaky crusts and an array of delectable fillings. Whether it was a classic apple pie or an enticing pecan pie, every bite elicited pure delight.

However, the pie that truly stole the show for me was the lemon meringue pie. The balance between the tangy lemon custard and the pillowy meringue was simply divine. It was like a burst of sunshine in my mouth, leaving me craving for more.

In addition to their fantastic pies, Bee's Knees Bakery also offers a wide variety of cupcakes. From rich chocolate to velvety red velvet, there was a cupcake flavor for every palate.

Overall, my visit to Bee's Knees Bakery was a delightful experience. Their pies are truly a work of art, and the flavors are second to none. So, if you find yourself in Athens and in need of a sweet treat, make sure to stop by Bee's Knees Bakery for a sensational pie that will leave you craving for seconds.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurant in Atlanta.

Donderos' Kitchen

Highlights
Unique menu
Well prepared
Relaxed setting
Friendly staff
Delicious grit boat

Walking into Donderos' Kitchen, I was immediately struck by the unique menu they offered. While I was there to find the best pie in Athens, I couldn't help but notice the variety of other delicious options available. However, my focus was solely on the pie.

The atmosphere at Donderos' Kitchen is warm and inviting, with a relaxed setting that makes you feel right at home. The friendly staff greeted me with a smile and made me feel welcomed the moment I stepped through the door.

When it came time to taste the pie, I was not disappointed. The pies at Donderos' Kitchen are well prepared, with a flaky crust that melts in your mouth and a filling that is perfectly balanced in flavor. Each bite was a delightful explosion of taste.

While all the pies were exceptional, there was one that truly stood out - the Delicious Grit Boat. This unique creation was a marvelous combination of savory and sweet. The creamy grits paired with a medley of vegetables and topped with a dollop of whipped cream created a symphony of flavors that left me craving for more.

To sum it up, I would highly recommend Donderos' Kitchen for anyone in search of the best pie in Athens. With their unique menu, well-prepared pies, relaxed setting, and friendly staff, this is a place where pie aficionados can find their taste buds dancing with joy.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Alpharetta.

Your Pie Pizza

I must say, I was blown away by the incredible selection of customizable pies at Your Pie Pizza in Athens. The sizzling and crispy crust was truly a work of art, while the toppings were fresh, flavorful, and plentiful. The staff was friendly and the atmosphere was relaxed, making it the perfect spot for a cheesy and satisfying meal. Trust me, you won't want to miss this pie sensation!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Atlanta.

Weaver D's Delicious Fine Foods

Weaver D's Delicious Fine Foods in Athens is a little slice of heaven. The moment I walked in, the tempting aroma of freshly baked pies hit my nose. The selection was mind-boggling, from classic apple to unique creations like chocolate bourbon pecan. Each bite was a flavor explosion, leaving me craving more. It's safe to say that Weaver D's pies are truly irresistible.

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Atlanta.