The Absolute Best Pie in Alpharetta [Updated 2025]

Throughout my culinary journey, I have had the pleasure of reviewing a total of eight pie establishments in the charming city of Alpharetta, Georgia. Brace yourself for an indulgent exploration into the world of flaky crusts and mouthwatering fillings as we unveil the top contenders vying for the prestigious title of the best pie in Alpharetta.

From classic fruit pies bursting with the freshest local produce to decadent, creamy creations that will transport you to dessert heaven, this comprehensive guide leaves no pie stone unturned. Prepare to embark on a delectable adventure as we uncover the hidden gems and undeniable favorites, all in the pursuit of the perfect pie!

Southern Baked Pie Company | Mail Order and Georgia Pie Shops

Highlights
Perfect gift for on-the-go clients
Top real estate team frequent go-to
Chicken Pot Pie household favorite
Simply amazing apple pie
Pies made with love

This hidden gem in Alpharetta proved to be a delightful discovery. The Southern Baked Pie Company not only satisfies your pie cravings, but it also offers a convenient mail order service for those on the go. It's the perfect gift for your on-the-go clients or a special treat for yourself.

As I walked into the cozy shop, the sweet aroma of freshly baked pies filled the air, igniting my taste buds with anticipation. With a reputation as a favorite among the local real estate teams, I knew that I was in for a treat.

First on my taste adventure was their renowned Chicken Pot Pie. The flaky crust and savory filling were a match made in pie heaven. It was pure comfort food at its finest, like receiving a warm hug from a loved one. It's no wonder why this pie has become a household favorite among locals.

Next, I couldn't resist trying their apple pie. The moment I took my first bite, I was transported to an orchard in the heart of Georgia. Simply amazing doesn't even begin to do justice to this pie. The thinly sliced apples were perfectly tender, bathing in a deliciously sweet cinnamon-spiced sauce. Every bite was a symphony of flavors that danced on my palate.

What sets the Southern Baked Pie Company apart is their commitment to making every pie with love. Each pie is crafted with care and attention to detail. Whether you're looking for a classic flavor or a unique twist, their wide variety of pies will satisfy every craving.

Overall, my experience at Southern Baked Pie Company | Mail Order and Georgia Pie Shops was nothing short of exceptional. From the warm and inviting atmosphere to the extraordinary flavors, it's clear that this place truly knows how to bake a pie that will leave you wanting more. If you're in Alpharetta and searching for the best pie in town, Southern Baked Pie Company has got you covered.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Marietta.

Alpine Bakery & Pizzeria / Crabapple

Highlights
Tasty food
Generous portions
Reasonably priced
Variety of desserts
Great service

From the moment I entered Alpine Bakery & Pizzeria / Crabapple, I knew I was in for a treat. The cozy atmosphere and delightful aroma of freshly baked goods were certainly promising signs. As I perused the menu, my eyes were immediately drawn to the section boasting their variety of desserts.

After much deliberation, I decided to indulge in their renowned pies. The extensive selection made it a tough decision, but I ultimately settled on a classic apple pie. Little did I know it would become a life-changing moment. Every bite was a burst of flavor, with a perfect balance of sweetness and tartness. The tasty filling was nestled in a flaky, buttery crust that left me craving for more.

Not only was the pie delicious, but the portion size was also incredibly generous. Each slice was overflowing with warm, fragrant apples, making it an ideal choice to satisfy any dessert craving. And the best part? The prices were reasonably priced for the quality and quantity you receive.

To top off my delightful experience, the great service provided by the friendly staff added an extra touch of satisfaction. They were attentive and knowledgeable, ensuring that every customer felt like a valued guest.

In conclusion, Alpine Bakery & Pizzeria / Crabapple is a must-visit for pie lovers in Alpharetta. With its delectable selection, generous portions, reasonable prices, and excellent service, it has undoubtedly earned its place among the contenders for the best pie in town. Don't miss out on the opportunity to indulge in a slice of pie perfection at this charming bakery.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurant in Atlanta.

Jerusalem Bakery & Grill

Highlights
Delicious food
Excellent service
Variety of options
Clean and inviting
Helpful staff

Walking into Jerusalem Bakery & Grill, I was immediately captivated by the delightful aroma of freshly baked goods. The atmosphere was clean and inviting, with a warm and friendly staff ready to assist me. I could already tell that this was going to be a memorable pie experience.

The menu boasted a variety of options, from classic favorites to unique creations. Unsure of what to choose, I sought the guidance of the helpful staff, who eagerly provided recommendations. The service was simply excellent, with smiles and attentive assistance throughout my entire visit.

As a pie enthusiast, the main attraction for me was, of course, the pies themselves. I am happy to report that each bite I took was a burst of pure pleasure. The crust was flaky and perfectly golden, while the fillings were rich and flavorful. From traditional apple pie to decadent chocolate cream, Jerusalem Bakery & Grill excelled in each and every creation.

The dedication to quality and attention to detail were evident in every slice. The flavors were not only vibrant but balanced, satisfying both my palate and my craving for a truly exceptional pie.

In conclusion, if you are on the hunt for the best pie in Alpharetta, Jerusalem Bakery & Grill should be at the top of your list. With their delicious food, excellent service, and variety of options, you won't be disappointed. Trust me, your taste buds will thank you for the delightful pie experience.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Alpharetta.

Theo's Brother's Bakery

I must say, the pies at Theo's Brother's Bakery were nothing short of divine. From the flaky crust to the mouthwatering fillings, each bite was a heavenly experience. The variety of flavors, from classic apple to unique creations like salted caramel pecan, made it impossible to choose just one favorite. Their attention to detail and commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients truly sets them apart. If you're searching for the best pie in Alpharetta, look no further than Theo's Brother's Bakery. Your taste buds will thank you!

You might also want to check out the best seafood market in Atlanta.

Crave Pie Studio

Crave Pie Studio in Alpharetta is a slice of heaven! With their innovative flavors and flaky crusts, their pies are a foodie's dream. From classic apple to unique creations like bourbon pecan, every bite is a delightful explosion of sweet and savory. Prepare to be pie-struck!

You might also want to check out the best affordable restaurants in Atlanta.

2B Whole Gluten-Free Bakery

In a playful yet professional style, I can confidently say that 2B Whole Gluten-Free Bakery in Alpharetta truly lives up to its name. Despite the gluten-free aspect, their pies possess a texture and taste that are remarkably satisfying. From their luscious fruit-filled treats to their decadent chocolate creations, there's a pie for everyone's palate. It's a must-visit for pie lovers in Alpharetta!

You might also want to check out the best seafood buffet in Atlanta.

Colette French Pastry & Café

Colette French Pastry & Café in Alpharetta is a delightful little spot that serves up scrumptious pies. Their flaky crusts and delectable fillings are divine. Whether you fancy a traditional apple pie or a unique flavor like honey lavender, Colette's pies are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. It's a must-visit for any pie lover in Alpharetta!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Atlanta.

The Cheesecake Factory

The Cheesecake Factory in Alpharetta certainly lives up to its reputation for decadent desserts. With a vast array of choices, their pies are definitely a standout. The crusts are flaky, fillings are rich, and the flavors are truly out of this world. Make sure to save room for a slice (or two) of their delicious pies!

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Atlanta.