The Absolute Best NY Pizza in Atlanta [Updated 2025]

Having reviewed a total of 12 pizza joints in Atlanta, I can confidently share with you the most delectable and authentic New York-style pizzas this city has to offer. From the cracker-like thin crusts to the gooey cheese and perfectly balanced toppings, the establishments on this list have truly mastered the art of crafting the best NY pizza experience outside of the Big Apple.

So, if you are a pizza aficionado or simply a fan of mouthwatering slices, get ready to embark on a delicious journey with me as I reveal the top spots to satisfy your cravings for the best NY pizza in Atlanta.

Ray's New York Pizza

Highlights
Owners are nice
Good and affordable food
Clean and friendly staff
No Flop
Solid Customer Service
Super Nice General Manager
Reasonable Prices
everything done right

Let me start by saying that the owners of Ray's New York Pizza are some of the nicest people you'll ever meet. From the moment I walked through the doors, I was greeted with a warm smile and a genuine desire to make my dining experience enjoyable.

Now let's talk about the food. Oh boy, it was good! Not only was it delicious, but it was also affordable. I could indulge in my love for pizza without breaking the bank. The crust was perfectly crispy, the sauce was tangy, and the cheese was just the right amount of gooey. And guess what? There was absolutely no flop. Each slice held its shape, making it a joy to eat.

But it's not just the food that impressed me. The cleanliness of the restaurant and the friendly staff added to the overall pleasant atmosphere. The solid customer service was evident in how attentive and kind the staff was throughout my visit.

It's worth mentioning that the general manager was super nice and went out of their way to ensure that everything was done right. From the moment I arrived, they made me feel like a valued customer.

And let's not forget about the reasonable prices. At Ray's New York Pizza, you can enjoy a delicious, authentic slice of New York pizza without emptying your wallet.

In conclusion, Ray's New York Pizza is a gem in the heart of Atlanta. With its friendly owners, good and affordable food, clean establishment, and solid customer service, it's a place that gets everything right. If you're in the mood for some top-notch ny pizza, don't hesitate to give Ray's a try. You won't be disappointed.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Atlanta.

Gino's NY Pizza Bar

Highlights
Great late night slice
Crispy crust
Variety of toppings
Meatball sub
Recommends the place

Gino's NY Pizza Bar in Atlanta is an absolute gem for all the late-night pizza cravings. As I stepped into the cozy and vibrant atmosphere, I knew I was in for a treat. The first thing that caught my attention was the extensive selection of toppings for their pizzas. From classic favorites like pepperoni and mushrooms to unique options like jalapenos and artichoke hearts, Gino's has something to satisfy every palate.

I started off with a classic cheese slice, and let me tell you, their crust is a thing of beauty. It delivers that perfect balance of crispiness and chewiness that I absolutely adore in a New York-style pizza. The cheese was perfectly melted, and the sauce had just the right amount of tanginess.

Feeling adventurous, I decided to try their signature meatball sub. Let me tell you, it was a game-changer. The meatballs were juicy and flavorful, nestled in a warm and fresh sub roll. The combination of flavors and textures was simply outstanding.

What impressed me the most about Gino's NY Pizza Bar was the attention to detail and quality in every dish. Each slice tasted like it was made with love and passion. The staff was friendly and knowledgeable, always ready to help with recommendations. It was obvious that they take pride in their craft.

If you're craving a slice of New York-style pizza in Atlanta, I highly recommend checking out Gino's NY Pizza Bar. You won't be disappointed. It's a place where late-night cravings are satisfied and your taste buds are given a real treat.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Atlanta.

Savage Pizza (Little 5 Points)

Highlights
Great staff
Trendy environment
Sour dough crust IS GOOD
Multiple special pizzas
Loved comic book art

From the moment I stepped into Savage Pizza, I was greeted by a warm and friendly staff that made me feel right at home. The trendy and vibrant environment immediately caught my attention, with its bold colors and quirky decor.

Now, let's talk about the star of the show - the pizza. I had heard great things about their sour dough crust and boy, did it live up to the hype. Each bite was a delightful combination of a crisp exterior and a chewy interior, creating the perfect foundation for the toppings.

Speaking of toppings, Savage Pizza offers a wide variety of options to satisfy any craving. From classic combinations to unique, specialty pizzas, there was something for everyone. I particularly enjoyed their special pizzas, which showcased their creativity and skill in crafting unique flavor profiles.

What sets Savage Pizza apart from other pizzerias is their love for comic book art. As I indulged in the delicious slices, I couldn't help but admire the walls adorned with vibrant illustrations. It added an extra element of enjoyment to my dining experience.

In conclusion, Savage Pizza in Little 5 Points is a hidden gem in Atlanta when it comes to New York style pizza. With its great staff, trendy environment, and a sour dough crust to die for, this pizzeria should be on every pizza lover's list. So, if you're looking for a place to satisfy your pizza cravings while immersing yourself in a playful atmosphere, don't miss out on a slice of Savage Pizza.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Atlanta.

Pizza Jeans

Pizza Jeans in Atlanta is an absolute gem when it comes to NY-style pizza! The dough was perfection – thin and crispy with a deliciously chewy center. Toppings were plentiful and fresh, and the sauce had just the right amount of tanginess. The combination of flavors was mind-blowing. This place is a must-try for any pizza lover in Atlanta!

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Marietta.

Junior's Pizza

Junior's Pizza in Atlanta has captured the essence of a true New York slice. Their crust is delightfully thin and crispy, and the cheese to sauce ratio is perfect. To top it off, their toppings are fresh and plentiful. I highly recommend giving Junior's a try on your quest for the best NY-style pizza in Atlanta.

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Atlanta.

Edgewood Pizzeria

Edgewood Pizzeria in Atlanta is a hidden gem for ny pizza aficionados. The tangy tomato sauce and the perfectly charred thin crust made my taste buds dance with joy. The bubbly mozzarella topping was to die for. This place screams authenticity and is definitely a contender for the best ny pizza in Atlanta!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Atlanta.

Pielands Sub and Slice

I must say, Pielands holds its own in the competitive Atlanta pizza scene. Their thin crust is crispy and delightfully foldable. Toppings are aplenty, with a perfect ratio of cheese to sauce. Grab a slice and discover a little taste of NY right in the heart of Atlanta!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Atlanta.

Antico Pizza Napoletana

Antico Pizza Napoletana is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in Atlanta. The thin crust, wood-fired pies here are a culinary masterpiece. The meltingly delicious mozzarella and flavor-packed tomato sauce make every bite a sensational experience. With its charming atmosphere and friendly staff, Antico is a top contender for the best NY pizza in Atlanta.

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Atlanta.

Slim & Husky's Pizza

Slim & Husky's Pizza in Atlanta delivers a bold and playful take on New York-style pizza. With their unique individual pies, homemade dough, and decadent toppings, it's clear they don't skimp on flavor. A must-try for pizza lovers in the city of Atlanta.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in Atlanta.

Max's Coal Oven Pizzeria

As an expert reviewer of ny pizzas, I recently had the pleasure of trying out Max's Coal Oven Pizzeria in Atlanta. Let me tell you, this place lives up to the hype! Their crust is perfectly thin and crispy, and the toppings are fresh and flavorful. It's like taking a bite out of the Big Apple right here in ATL! Don't miss out on this delectable gem in the heart of the city.

You might also want to check out the best pancakes in Atlanta.

Vinny's N.Y. Pizza & Grill - Midtown

Vinny's N.Y. Pizza & Grill - Midtown in Atlanta is a slice of heaven for pizza lovers like me. Their authentic New York-style pizzas are a culinary masterpiece, with the perfect balance of crispy crust, gooey cheese, and flavorful toppings. The service was prompt and the atmosphere was cozy. Vinny's is definitely a top contender for the best NY pizza in Atlanta!

Johnny's New York Style Pizza

Johnny's New York Style Pizza in Atlanta is a game-changer! Their pizza is truly authentic with a crispy thin crust that is perfectly charred. The toppings are abundant and flavorful, and I couldn't resist going for seconds. This place definitely deserves a spot on the best ny pizza in Atlanta list!