The Absolute Best New York Style Pizza in Atlanta [Updated 2025]

Throughout my extensive career, I have sampled countless new york style pizzas in Atlanta, and today I am excited to share my top picks with you. After personally reviewing a staggering total of 12 pizzerias in the city, I have finally narrowed down the finest establishments that truly embody the authenticity and flavors reminiscent of the bustling streets of New York.

Prepare your taste buds for a delectable journey as we explore the best new york style pizza in Atlanta. So, whether you are a local seeking a satisfying slice or a visitor longing for a taste of the Big Apple, this article will guide you in the right direction.

Savage Pizza (Little 5 Points)

Highlights
Great staff
Trendy environment
Sour dough crust IS GOOD
Multiple special pizzas
Comic book art

As soon as I walked into Savage Pizza, I was greeted by a great staff who were friendly and attentive. The trendy environment immediately caught my eye, with its vibrant colors and quirky decorations. The restaurant's walls were adorned with fascinating comic book art, creating a unique and playful atmosphere.

Of course, what matters most when it comes to pizza is the taste. Savage Pizza did not disappoint. Their sour dough crust had just the right amount of chewiness and crispiness. It had a distinct flavor that elevated the entire pizza-eating experience. I couldn't help but think to myself, this crust is good!

One of the things that sets Savage Pizza apart is their wide variety of special pizzas. They offer an array of unique toppings and combinations, allowing customers to try something different each visit. From the savoury depths of the "Savage Veggie" to the mouthwatering perfection of the "Carnivore's Delight," there is a pizza to satisfy every craving.

In addition to their delicious pizza, Savage Pizza also provides an extensive menu of other Italian delights, including hot heroes, salads, and calzones. No matter what your preference, they've got you covered.

Overall, my visit to Savage Pizza was a delightful experience that I would highly recommend to anyone searching for the best New York style pizza in Atlanta. The combination of great staff, trendy environment, flavorful sour dough crust, mouthwatering special pizzas, and captivating comic book art makes Savage Pizza a standout choice. Don't miss out on this gem in the heart of Atlanta's Little 5 Points.

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Atlanta.

Gino's NY Pizza Bar

Highlights
Late night eat
Crispy crust
Affordable specials
Delicious meatball sub
Friendly staff

Upon entering Gino's NY Pizza Bar, I was immediately greeted by the mouthwatering aroma of freshly baked pizza. The friendly staff made me feel right at home, ready to embark on my delicious pizza journey.

One highlight of Gino's NY Pizza Bar is their late-night eats. As a night owl myself, it's a delight to know that I can satisfy my pizza cravings even after midnight. Who says pizza should have a curfew? Gino's NY Pizza Bar certainly doesn't think so!

As for the pizza itself, the crust was crispy and had that perfect balance of chewiness. Oh, heavenly delight! Whether I devoured a classic pepperoni or indulged in a gourmet vegetable pizza, each bite took me straight to the streets of New York. It was like teleportation via pizza!

What sets Gino's NY Pizza Bar apart is their affordability, especially with their specials. They offer delicious deals that won't break the bank. But don't let the price fool you; the quality of their pizza is top-notch.

Now, let me give a shout-out to the meatball sub. It was a delightful surprise, overflowing with flavorful meatballs smothered in a tantalizing marinara sauce. I couldn't resist the temptation to take a big bite, and trust me, it did not disappoint.

In conclusion, if you're searching for the best New York style pizza in Atlanta, look no further than Gino's NY Pizza Bar. With their late-night eats, crispy crust, affordable specials, and their delicious meatball sub, Gino's NY Pizza Bar is the ultimate destination for a taste of the Big Apple.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Atlanta.

Ray's New York Pizza

Highlights
Affordable
Friendly
Clean kitchen
Solid Service
Authentic NY

Walking into Ray's New York Pizza, I was immediately drawn in by the enticing aroma of freshly baked dough and aromatic tomato sauce wafting through the air. The atmosphere was cozy, with classic New York memorabilia adorning the walls and friendly staff behind the counter.

First things first, the prices at Ray's were exceptionally affordable, making it a great spot for a casual lunch or quick dinner. As I perused the menu, I noticed a variety of toppings and specialty pies to choose from. Opting for a classic cheese slice, I eagerly awaited my first bite.

When my slice arrived, I couldn't help but notice the authentic New York style in every aspect. The crust was thin and slightly crisp, providing the perfect balance to the rich, tangy tomato sauce and gooey, melted cheese. Each bite transported me to the bustling streets of Manhattan.

What impressed me even more was the cleanliness of the kitchen. The staff worked diligently, ensuring that every pie was crafted with care and attention to detail. The solid service provided an added touch of warmth to the overall experience.

In conclusion, Ray's New York Pizza delivered an amazing taste of the Big Apple right here in Atlanta. With its friendly atmosphere, affordable prices, and authentic flavors, it's no wonder why this place stands out amongst the sea of pizza joints in the city. So, if you're in the mood for a satisfying and authentic New York style pizza, Ray's should be at the top of your list.

You might also want to check out the best fried chicken in Atlanta.

Edgewood Pizzeria

Arriving at Edgewood Pizzeria, my taste buds were instantly transported to the streets of New York. The irresistible aroma of freshly baked crust and tangy tomato sauce filled the air. The thin and crispy crust was a delight, perfectly complementing the generous toppings of gooey cheese and savory pepperoni. It's a must-try for any pizza lover in Atlanta.

You might also want to check out the best restaurants in Marietta.

Glide Pizza

Glide Pizza in Atlanta is a slice of heaven! This hidden gem has truly mastered the art of New York style pizza. The crust is thin and crispy, with just the right amount of chewiness. The sauce is tangy and flavorful, and the cheese is ooey-gooey perfection. I highly recommend trying their pepperoni pizza, it's out of this world! Go grab yourself a slice at Glide Pizza and experience pure pizza bliss.

You might also want to check out the best donuts in Atlanta.

Ammazza Edgewood

I must say, the dough at Ammazza Edgewood was dreamy and reminded me of the big apple! The cheese was ooey-gooey and the sauce had just the right amount of tang. Each bite transported me to the bustling streets of New York. Trust me, this place is a pizza lover's paradise!

You might also want to check out the best italian food in Atlanta.

Pizza Jeans

I must say, Pizza Jeans truly nailed the New York style pizza game in Atlanta. Their thin, crispy crust and perfectly melty cheese made each bite an absolute delight. And can we talk about the generous toppings? Mamma mia! From the savory pepperoni to the fresh basil, it was a flavor explosion in my mouth. The friendly staff and cozy decor only added to the experience. If you're on the hunt for the best New York style pizza in Atlanta, look no further than Pizza Jeans!

You might also want to check out the best bagels in Atlanta.

Max's Coal Oven Pizzeria

Max's Coal Oven Pizzeria in Atlanta is a cheesy delight. Their thin and crispy crust is cooked to perfection in their authentic coal oven. Each bite of their flavorful and saucy slices evoked memories of the streets of New York City. It's definitely a contender for the title of the best New York style pizza in Atlanta.

You might also want to check out the best casual restaurants in Atlanta.

Junior's Pizza

Junior's Pizza in Atlanta is a slice of NYC in the ATL. The foldable crust, gooey cheese, and zesty sauce will transport you straight to the streets of Brooklyn. The atmosphere is laid-back, and the friendly staff adds to the authentic experience. This pizzeria is definitely a contender for the best NY-style pizza in Atlanta.

You might also want to check out the best pasta in Atlanta.

Pielands Sub and Slice

Oh, Pielands Sub and Slice, what a charming little spot amidst the hustle and bustle of Atlanta! The moment I stepped in, the inviting aroma of freshly baked pizzas filled the air, luring me to their display of mouthwatering slices. Their New York style pizza was a work of art, with a crispy yet chewy crust and a tangy tomato sauce that danced atop a bed of melted mozzarella. Each bite was an explosion of flavors, making me feel as if I had been teleported to the streets of the Big Apple. The selection of toppings was impressive, ranging from classic pepperoni to unique creations like the buffalo chicken. The friendly staff and cozy ambiance added to the delightful experience. Pielands Sub and Slice has truly mastered the art of crafting authentic New York style pizza. I am thrilled to include them in my list of the best New York style pizzas in Atlanta.

You might also want to check out the best pancakes in Atlanta.

Johnny's New York Style Pizza

I took a bite of their cheesy and delicious pizza and felt like I was teleported to the streets of the Big Apple. The crispy crust and generous toppings were a match made in pizza heaven. Johnny's New York Style Pizza is a must-try for any pizza enthusiast in Atlanta.

Vinny's N.Y. Pizza & Grill - Midtown

Vinny's N.Y. Pizza & Grill - Midtown in Atlanta served up true New York style pizza that had me feeling like I was taking a bite out of the Big Apple. The thin, crispy crust and generous toppings were a delightful treat. So, if you're on the hunt for the best New York style pizza in Atlanta, Vinny's should be on your list.