The Absolute Best Ice Cream in Athens [Updated 2025]

Throughout my career as an ice cream expert, I have had the delightful opportunity to sample and review countless ice cream parlors in Athens, GA. Today, I am excited to share with you my top recommendations for the best ice cream in this charming city.

With my discerning taste buds and extensive knowledge of the local ice cream scene, I have carefully reviewed a total of eight establishments, all vying for the title of the best ice cream in Athens. So, whether you're a local looking to satisfy your sweet tooth or a visitor in search of a delectable frozen treat, this guide is all you need to uncover the finest ice cream Athens has to offer.

Bruster's Real Ice Cream

Highlights
Best ice cream
Wonderful service
Incredible selection

Bruster's Real Ice Cream in Athens truly lives up to its reputation as one of the best ice cream spots in town. From the moment I walked in, I could tell I was in for a treat.

What struck me first was the incredible selection of flavors they offered. From classic favorites like chocolate and vanilla to more unique and adventurous options like salted caramel pretzel and black raspberry, there was truly something for everyone. It was a delightful struggle to choose just one flavor!

But what sets Bruster's apart from other ice cream shops is not just their amazing ice cream, it's also their wonderful service. The staff at Bruster's is friendly, helpful, and genuinely passionate about their ice cream. They were more than happy to offer recommendations, let me try samples, and answer any questions I had.

And speaking of the ice cream, it was divine. Each scoop was rich, creamy, and bursting with flavor. The texture was perfectly smooth, and the balance between sweetness and creaminess was on point. It was evident that Bruster's takes great care in using high-quality ingredients to create their ice cream masterpieces.

Overall, Bruster's Real Ice Cream in Athens is a must-visit for any ice cream lover. With its incredible selection, wonderful service, and top-notch ice cream, it's no wonder that Bruster's is considered one of the best in town. So, next time you're in Athens, be sure to stop by Bruster's and indulge in some truly exceptional ice cream.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Marietta.

Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams

Highlights
Exceptional ice cream
Friendly staff
Great flavor selections

Let me tell you, the ice cream at Jeni's is nothing short of exceptional. From the moment I stepped in, the sweet aroma of freshly churned ice cream tickled my senses. With an array of vibrant and enticing flavors on display, I knew I was in for a treat.

The staff at Jeni's is not only knowledgeable but also incredibly friendly. They are more than happy to help you navigate through their extensive selection of flavors. I found it refreshing to see their enthusiasm and passion for ice cream. They truly made the experience delightful.

Speaking of flavors, let me assure you, Jeni's does not disappoint. Whether you have a penchant for classic favorites like rich chocolate or adventurous palates seeking exotic combinations like lavender and honey or salted caramel with smoked almonds, they have it all. The options seem endless, and each scoop is a burst of flavor that will transport you to ice cream paradise.

One aspect that sets Jeni's apart from the rest is the quality of their ingredients. Their commitment to sourcing local and seasonal ingredients is reflected in the vibrant and authentic flavors of their ice creams. You can truly taste the difference.

In conclusion, if you find yourself wandering the streets of Athens in search of the best ice cream, I highly recommend paying a visit to Jeni's Splendid Ice Creams. The exceptional ice cream, friendly staff, and great flavor selections make it a must-visit destination for any ice cream aficionado. Don't miss out on this delightful experience!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Marietta.

Ben & Jerry’s

Highlights
Friendly and welcoming atmosphere
Excellent customer service
Engaging and entertaining staff

Walking into Ben & Jerry’s in Athens, I was immediately struck by the friendly and welcoming atmosphere. The staff seemed genuinely excited to be there, and their enthusiasm was contagious. They greeted me with bright smiles and a warm welcome, making me feel right at home.

The customer service at Ben & Jerry’s was top-notch. The staff was knowledgeable about the different flavors and were more than happy to help me choose the perfect ice cream for my taste buds. They took the time to explain each flavor and even offered me samples to try before making a decision. Their patience and willingness to assist in finding the perfect scoop was truly remarkable.

But what really set Ben & Jerry’s apart was their engaging and entertaining staff. As I enjoyed my ice cream, the staff performed a lively and fun song and dance routine, leaving everyone in the shop with smiles on their faces. It was clear that they loved what they do, and their joy was infectious.

The ice cream itself lived up to the hype. The flavors were rich and creamy, with just the right balance of sweetness. Each spoonful was a delectable treat for my taste buds. Whether you're a fan of classics like Chocolate Fudge Brownie or more adventurous flavors like Cherry Garcia, Ben & Jerry’s has a flavor to satisfy every craving.

Overall, my experience at Ben & Jerry’s in Athens was delightful. The combination of a friendly atmosphere, excellent customer service, and engaging staff made for a memorable visit. If you're looking for the best ice cream in Athens, don't miss out on the deliciousness that Ben & Jerry’s has to offer.

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurant in Atlanta.

University of Georgia Creamery

Hey there! As an expert ice cream connoisseur, I couldn't resist visiting the delightful University of Georgia Creamery in Athens. Nestled in the heart of this vibrant city, it's a treat worth licking your lips for. The flavors are bold, the textures are creamy, and the staff's expertise shines through every scrumptious scoop. A must-visit for any ice cream lover exploring Athens.

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Atlanta.

Cool World Ice Cream Shop

Cool World Ice Cream Shop in Athens was a sweet surprise! The huge selection of flavors was mind-blowing, and the creaminess of the ice cream was out of this world. From classics like chocolate and vanilla, to unique creations like lavender honey and pistachio fig, there was something for everyone. The friendly staff and cozy atmosphere made it the perfect spot to indulge in a scoop (or two) of heaven. Don't miss out on this cool gem in Athens!

You might also want to check out the best seafood restaurants in Alpharetta.

La Michoacana Antojitos Mexicanos

La Michoacana Antojitos Mexicanos in Athens is a hidden gem bursting with flavorful and authentic ice cream. The vibrant and cheerful atmosphere adds to the fun of choosing from their extensive selection of mouthwatering flavors. Don't miss their rich and creamy Mexican-inspired creations like the tropical mango or the spicy chocolate chili. A true fiesta for the taste buds!

You might also want to check out the best ice cream in Alpharetta.

Andy's Frozen Custard

Andy's Frozen Custard in Athens is a sweet haven for ice cream lovers like me. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with a delightful aroma of freshly made waffle cones. The creamy and decadent flavors had me hooked, especially the Salted Caramel Concrete that made my taste buds dance with delight. The impeccable customer service added a cherry on top of the experience. For an unforgettable ice cream adventure, head straight to Andy's Frozen Custard in Athens!

You might also want to check out the best pizza in Atlanta.

Baskin-Robbins

In just 50 words:

Madness of flavors! Baskin-Robbins in Athens brought me to a world of delightful ice creams. Their extensive menu kept me spoilt for choice. From classic flavors to unique creations, the options were endless. The creamy texture and bold flavors made this spot a top contender for the best ice cream in Athens.

You might also want to check out the best bbq in Atlanta.